Behind the Scenes with Stunning Candidates…What are they saying about YOU?

By Catherine Cunningham - Career Specialist - Australia

Share on: 

Photo by Yvan Musy on Unsplash 

Lean, agile and dynamic?

Hmmm… Would that describe you and your recruitment practices?


Guess Who’s in the Driving Seat?

Finally, in 2018 it seems the tide is changing and power is swinging back to good candidates.

Part of my job as a careers specialist is to use my knowledge of current recruitment practices to help my clients. Along the way, I hear all sorts of stories about behaviour from hiring organisations that alienates the best and the brightest.

If you’re after a top candidate, here’s some off the record feedback about easily-avoidable traps so that the stars willingly and eagerly sign on board with you.


1. Don’t pin your candidates down at the start when it comes to salary.

‘Their stupid website wouldn’t let me finish the application unless I put my current salary in. I wanted to put $0 in just to shut them up.’

As more and more organisations insist that even Executives apply via their online recruitment portal, it is time for you to do an external review of how appealing or, more importantly, how alienating your process is. 

I have had many a conversation with a senior executive who is both frustrated and furious at being expected to nominate a specific salary in a text box before being able to move on. This is an issue on so many levels:

  • An Executive may be looking to trade up or indeed down when it comes to salary. They worry that they will price themselves out of the job, almost before they start.
  • Many executives pride themselves on their ability to negotiate a fair salary. They are highly offended at the crudeness of being expected to pluck a single number out of the air without any actual negotiation.
  • Many executives are angry at being asked to disclose this information so early in the recruitment dance. It sours their first impression of your organisation. 

Effectively, you are asking the employee to help you to negotiate against them. Quite unreasonable.


2.     Show respect. Do what you said you were going to do.

Photo by Aidas Ciziunas on Unsplash

‘They said they’d call and let me know before the weekend. But they didn’t. I didn’t want to put my life on hold anymore so I accepted the other job.’

These days, most service providers send you a text reminder about an upcoming appointment and can be quite strict about charging cancellation fees. Time is clearly money. 

It’s no different with your candidate. Good candidates are busy people with lots happening in their lives.

At a minimum, you should quickly contact a candidate to advise of any delay. One delay is probably reasonable; the more you keep shifting and changing, the more foolish and incompetent you start to look. What amazes me is that so many organisations don’t seem to mind or be embarrassed by this. 

Don’t expect your candidates to wait until you deign to contact them.


3.      Don’t be a sloth. Move the process along with speed.

Photo by Javier Mazzeo on Unsplash

 ‘If they’re as inefficient running their business as they have been in their dealings with me, I don’t actually want to work for them.’

Do I even need to mention this one? I’m yet to receive my first online delivery deposited by a drone but apparently, that day is not far off. Surely in this day and age, any astute Manager realizes that candidates will judge an organization which moves slowly very severely.

Just think it through. If someone is applying for your role, it generally means that they want to leave their current role. Do you really think that yours is the only job that they are applying for? My clients generally have at least 6-10 advertised opportunities that they are investigating at any one time, let alone the leads they may be chasing through Job Search Networking.

Government and the Not For Profit sector are particularly bad culprits here. It is more understandable in government roles which almost always require a panel of people to choose the shortlist and then to be available at the same time to interview the candidates. There is no excuse for the NFP sector.

As a general aside, many Executives in the NFP sector come from government and bring those clunky recruitment processes across with them by default. It might be time to do some research about best practice and bring yourselves up to date.


4.      Those dreaded criteria.

Photo by Cris Saur on Unsplash

 ‘I was in the middle of answering my tenth criterion when the system crashed. I just gave up. It was SO boring. I had two other jobs I was applying for and couldn’t be bothered starting again.’  

If the private sector can manage to recruit using a Cover Letter and a résumé as the basis for deciding who to interview, why can’t the NFP sector? Again, it is a hangover from old-fashioned processes used by the government.

I can remember helping a young family member who was asked to address 14 criteria in a two-page letter. When I phoned the HR Manager and respectfully suggested that this was not possible, I was gobsmacked by her response, ‘Oh, just choose a few to answer.’ What an unfair choice to expect a young graduate to make! How about learning to assess the content of a résumé to see if the candidate has what you are after? (You can tell that I was particularly hot under the collar about that one.)


5.      Avoid win-lose in the contract negotiation process.

‘I felt like they slapped me down. They’ll only give me 3 months pay if they terminate my contract without cause.’

Once someone starts in your job, their redundancy entitlement reverts to zero. My CFO client knew that it would take her several months to find another role if she was made redundant unexpectedly. So, she asked for a 6-month payout if this occurred. I often call this a contingent liability in that the organisation only has to pay it out if they are engineering the change, in which case they should be paying it out. It could also be viewed as an insurance policy that the employee takes out with you.

Any senior executive without some reasonable parachute clause is clearly going to be uneasy in the job. More to the point, an employment contract is an essential part of protecting the interests of both the employee and the organisation. Why would you not expect executives to want to protect themselves? Why would you not allow them to protect themselves? 


6.      Understand that the candidate will be evaluating you just as much as you are evaluating them.

Photo by Sam Carter on Unsplash

 ‘He was quite rude to a fellow staff member who took his meeting room by mistake. The other guy didn’t know where to look.’

 My client, Rob, had checked out his prospective new boss on LinkedIn and found someone who knew him. The feedback he received was a bit lukewarm, so I suppose that Rob was already wary when he experienced that behavior before his interview started.

Rob was invited back for a second interview but ended up turning down the job offer. There were too many bad signs and he had too many other prospects.


7.      Behave properly in the interview. Obey Body Language rules.

 Photo by Valentino Funghi on Unsplash 

‘He seemed to think that vigorously pumping my hand as he met me would make up for the fact that he never looked me in the eye during the interview. Well, it didn’t. There was nothing fun about that interview.’

The HR Director had stated that he would not be looking at my client during the interview as he wanted to take notes. Now, our society has strict Body Language rules, but he clearly thought that his need over-rode basic manners.

Perhaps the HR Director also had the very old-fashioned notion that he, as the prospective employer, held all the power. You know what I mean…’I’m the interviewer and I’ll decide what happens here’.

As Julia Roberts said in Pretty Woman, ‘Bad move’.

My client had previously identified Fun & Humour as being essential for her to be happy at work. Need I say that she turned down the role?


Recruitment in Boom Times

The whole world is a small place these days when it comes to a bad reputation.

Do you actually know what reputation your organisation has when it comes to recruitment?

How does your organisation score in relation to the above issues?

Have you ever had an outsider audit your methods against Best Practice? (Mind you, I’d just settle for reasonable practice.)

Why not start with an approach which recognises that recruitment is a process where both parties have power?

Why not make it fast and efficient?

But most of all, why not make it respectful?

Just today, one of my clients spoke warmly about a wonderful Recruiter she was dealing with in relation to an advertised role. It can be done.




Catherine Cunningham is Adelaide's leading career expert.  She appears regularly in The Weekend Australian Careers section, in The Advertiser's Careers section, as well as in online publications such as,, and

About the company

The Social Hire team don't just do social media.

The social media marketers in our company are the best in the business at helping our partners enhance their online marketing. We outline and implement cutting-edge social media marketing plans that help our customers realise their organisational objectives and further their social media presence. Our experienced team of digital experts do your social media strategy creation and management in an uncomplicated monthly plan that is cost-effective and is genuinely useful, whatever results you demand from your marketing team.

Our specialists are a team that assists our partners improve their presence online by giving online marketing on a regular basis.

You might like these blog posts Video Marketing Trends in 2017, Winning Combo for Local Businesses: Geofencing and Social Media, Why do Facebook ads work for small businesses?, and Starting Up Part 2: Conquering the Lean Startup Phase.

  Back to Recruitment blogs